Submissions
More Links
9 September 2026 House of Representatives
Submission to House of Representatives Standing Committee on Health, Aged Care and Disability inquiry into access
to and affordability of medical non-GP specialists in Australia.
Prepared by Dr Tim Woodruff, President DRS
Download file
Thank you for the opportunity to contribute to the debate about this crucially important issue.
We note the very broad Terms of Reference and will comment briefly on some of these but wish to concentrate predominantly on the affordability of non-GP specialist services and the geographical distribution of such services.
However, we would like to suggest firstly that the current discussion from the minister and others in the media has generally been about the non-GP specialist co-payments limiting access to care, as well as the geographical problems for rural and remote communities. We suggest that that emphasis is incorrect and that the discussion should be framed around providing adequate public inpatient and outpatient services so that there is no need for any patient to seek private care unless they can afford it and wish to have private care.
a) Examine current access to medical non-GP specialists in cities, regional and rural communities, with consideration of workforce distribution, shortages, waiting times and barriers to recruitment, retention and training.
Others with access to much larger resources than us will undoubtably provide evidence indicating current access to medical non-GP specialists and to in hospital services is clearly limited by both cost and distribution of services and will indicate various contributing factors to these limitations including the ones listed above.
The very fact that there are years long waiting times to access public hospital outpatient services is a clear indicator that patients either can’ t afford the private copayment or, even if they can, they know that there are likely to be further copayments for investigations which they will struggle to afford.
Public hospitals triage patients on waiting lists. They stratify them according to immediacy of need. However, as well as straightforward waiting times, there are the waiting times to be triaged which is often months. Then, if need changes, a further referral may well be acted on appropriately, but that change will also take months. Whilst similar types of delays also occur in the private system, they are almost always much shorter.
It is very clear to us that a wind-surfing chef who develops an overuse syndrome of a tendon at his wrist which is more attributable to his windsurfing than his occupation but then has to wait without work for 2 years for the necessary operation, is discriminated against by the system. His retired neighbour develops an identical problem which prevents him playing golf but only for 2 months because his private health insurance enables him to access care almost immediately.
The inequalities of the system are also very clear to us when we have patients who need an elective joint replacement forced to wait 18 months, limping in pain around the house on a walking frame, dealing with narcotic side effects, unable to participate properly in family life, often being a burden on family members who are willing to support them but shouldn’t have to. The neighbour’s joint replacement gets done through the private system within months of the need being identified.
b) Examine the effectiveness, transparency and equity of referral pathways from the perspective of patients, primary health care practitioners and medical non-GP specialists across the public and private health sectors, with consideration of factors affecting referral patterns and any systemic, regulatory or administrative barriers to the appropriate utilisation of these pathways.
There are widespread differences in referral pathways to non-GP specialist outpatients in public hospitals. In some cases, non-medically trained staff judge the referral as appropriate and reject if they view it as not e.g. a referral to an osteoporosis clinic rejected because no menopausal history was included: the patient’s name was John. In other cases, the referral can be sorted by the triaging non- GP specialist with a letter to the GP suggesting investigations prior to attendance. Standard referral templates at public hospitals often require completely unnecessary tests when non-medical staff make the initial assessment of the referral. The public system can, however, be much more efficient than the private system (but not as remunerative for the private non-GP specialist as they might like). Thus, if a non-GP specialist triages the patient, they can decide if the referral is indeed necessary and if the standard required tests are indeed useful. They may be able to inform the GP that the referral isn’t necessary, or that extra tests can be done beforehand, and override requests for unnecessary tests. This can be done via a letter or other communication. As a salaried non-GP specialist that is efficient and the non-GP specialist is paid for their time. This already happens in a very limited way in some hospitals with innovative non-GP specialists. A private non-GP specialist probably won’t do that because time is money and there is no rebate for such a service.
c) Examine the affordability of non-GP specialist services, including out of pocket costs for consultations, diagnostics, procedures, and patient access to non-GP specialists through public health services, as well as factors influencing fee setting by non-GP specialists in the public and private health sectors.
You will be aware that in the community the cost of non-GP specialist services, including simply the first consultation and relatively simple diagnostics and procedures that only take an hour or so, is indeed unaffordable to many of our patients. Such patients therefore go on waiting lists at public hospitals firstly to get an appointment and then, if a procedure is needed, to wait for that on another waiting list. Many of the non-GP specialists who see these patients on the waiting list also have private practices where they charge co-payments, which forces patients to see them publicly. After a long wait they do that with the full knowledge that the co-payments they charge will mean that such patients will wait whilst the patients who can afford their services in private will not have to wait.
Reasons for copayments
We suggest that this is for three main reasons. The first is the sense of entitlement of non-GP specialists who feel that the income generated by the co-payments is necessary for them to live the lifestyle which they deserve. Many of them work extremely hard, long hours, and have little time for family. They benefit from these long hours by a sense of achievement, a reward that comes from the kind of work they do. But they also benefit financially and this financial benefit enables them to have the luxuries of life but also means that they have access to affordable and timely healthcare at a standard often much higher than the patients they see in public hospitals. It also means their children’s educational opportunities are much higher than their average public hospital patient.
The second main reason for these co-payments being sufficient to prevent access to many in the community is more subtle. Non-GP specialists look around their colleagues and notice what they are charging. Some would feel that the charges of other non-GP specialists are excessive and they definitely charge significantly lower copayments than some of their colleagues, so they feel they are being much fairer and less greedy than their colleagues. However, the co-payments they charge are still sufficient to prevent patients accessing their care and being forced to go on to waiting lists to see them at the public hospital.
The third main reason for these co-payments is the grossly inadequate competition in the community and at public hospitals for access to non-GP specialist community services, whether they be consultations or simple diagnostic procedures. This is directly the fault of the public hospitals choosing not to employ sufficient non-GP specialists and trying to remain within budget, and avoiding even longer waiting times for surgery, but it is also a fault of the state governments, which don’t give them sufficient funds to employ enough non-GP specialists to staff outpatients.
A recent example of this comes from a major Melbourne teaching hospital which advertised for a 0.5 Head of Department position in a medical specialty and a specialist applied, was told they were successful, and then told that the position would only be 0.2. When this was queried, the applicant was told that they had no interest in expanding this particular specialty and no more sessions would be made available. Waiting times for appointments can be over 6 months.
However, the Federal Government is responsible for somewhat less than half the cost of running public hospitals. It too is directly at fault because:
1. It doesn’t fund public hospitals with sufficient amounts to provide adequate outpatient services. 2. It doesn’t attempt to direct the funds it provides into adequate outpatient services.
It is worth noting here just how disorganised and inconsistent the funding of public hospital out-patients is. In Victoria state governments provide public hospitals with a budget and they employ non-GP specialists. However, some public hospitals in Victoria partly fund outpatient services through the federal government rebate and take the bulk billing rebate and then top it up with their own funds to make up the salary of the non-GP specialist and to pay on-costs. But some public hospitals in Victoria do it all by themselves and just rely on the federal government to give the usual percentage that happens with all public hospitals. We do not know how widespread this gaming of Medicare is across Australia.
However, it is a saving for the public hospitals but almost certainly is more expensive for the health system overall in that there are administrative requirements required to bulk bill patients and do the accounting associated with these payments. In addition, potentially it is requiring non-GP specialists to see every patient, which may be quite unnecessary and inefficient on quite a lot of occasions when the senior registrar is reviewing a patient whose condition is stable.
d) Examine the impact on patient outcomes by delays due to cost, distance and waiting times, and broader system impacts on primary care, emergency departments, public hospitals, chronic disease management, as well as impacts on people due to deferred or missed care,
The impact of delayed care essentially means that patients and their families relying on the public system suffer and die more than those who can access the private system. Others may document the numbers and specifics but the above is the reality.
e) Assess innovative and emerging models of care that may improve access to medical non-GP specialists
The first two reasons for excessive co-payments are not easily amenable to change. It has been suggested that the Medicare rebate be not paid to those who charge extremely high co-payments. Whilst this would address the very tip of the excessive co-payment iceberg, it would also be a complicated change, possibly requiring a High Court challenge, and would take quite some time to implement.
We suggest something considerably simpler. What is required is adequate publicly funded non-GP specialist services to the point where patients who wish to go private do so because they want to go private, not because they don’t want to wait the inordinately long times to get public care. This would mean that those who are paying such co-payments are choosing to because they wish to have private care and they can afford it. But non-GP specialists who currently rely on the many patients who really stretch their finances to get private care because of the waits for the public system, may then find that lowering their copayments will maintain their market share.
Options
We suggest the federal government consider two options. Firstly, it could provide a hypothecated amount of funding for public hospital outpatients. Whilst this could be done as an addition to the current outpatient services, the risk would be that public hospitals would diminish what they are doing currently and have no overall increase in our patient services.
The more complex second option which would avoid states reducing their input to public outpatients as in the first option, would be for the Federal government to take over outpatient services in their entirety. They could determine how much less they would contribute to state government budgets so that inpatient services continue but still provide sufficient funds to establish competition from public outpatients to private consultations and services.
This service could include hospital outpatients but also community clinics where non-GP specialists would be seen away from the hospital so that the geographical barriers to access might also be improved.
It would be necessary however, that each clinic of this type was directly linked to a public hospital. States differ in the way they run hospital networks, and it would have to be linked in through the hospital network, whatever the arrangement that state has.
The Federal Government has opened multiple urgent care clinics to provide general practice consultations in the community. It is willing to pay the general practitioners a significant salary for working in these clinics. If they were to set up and run public hospital outpatients with community non- GP specialist clinics, the non-GP specialist would be paid a salary similar to that already paid in a public hospital.
One argument against this might be that non-GP specialists won’t want to give up their private practice to work in the public system. There are plenty of non-GP specialists who already work in the public system, part-time or full-time. Recently graduated non-GP specialists might be very keen to have an immediate well-funded position as a non-GP specialist without taking on the complexities of private practice or indeed easing themselves very gradually into private practice.
Such clinics could be staffed by not only non-GP specialists but training registrars, permanently employed assistants (medical officers or otherwise) and general practitioners. One consultant can manage a much larger number of patients with appropriate support. With the increasing complexity of management of many chronic conditions some long-term follow-up is often needed in non-GP specialist clinics. Properly supported ancillary staff can take much of the workload with
the consultant immediately available.
Additional Improvements
Access for GPs to non-GP specialist advice
Non-GP specialist advice should be immediately available to GPs, either by phone or e-mail. This could be done centrally with ‘call centres’. Locally available services would allow proper referral when urgent as opposed to adding another layer to the process. Outreach/Telehealth
Outreach services are becoming more common but could be better integrated between the larger centre and regional areas. Telehealth is a great advance but having some personal contact at some point is also invaluable. Formalising sub-specialty services in regional areas with properly resourced fly –in/fly out staff who provide the tertiary services when needed would be one away around the problem of attracting non-GP specialists to regional areas.
Non-GP training in ‘office’ subspecialities
A further option to increase availability of non-GP specialists would be to negotiate with the non-GP specialist colleges to redefine training programs to better meet the needs of the population.
In Britain there exists the specialty of office urology. Such urologists perform cystoscopies in offices or day facilities and consult but do no other surgery. Training time is less. There are numerous opportunities to ‘fast-track’ non-GP specialists by limiting their breadth of practice (and therefore duration of training. Do all cardiologists need to learn to do angiography, could there be a specialty of ophthalmology limited to cataract surgery? Do all endoscopists need to be fully trained gastroenterologists? There is a place to limit training in endocrinology to only diabetes or neurology to only stroke medicine. Office ear nose and throat medicine is probably an option.
Public hospitals
Importantly, for outpatient services to provide timely affordable care to those who need it and can’t afford private care, there also needs to be an improvement in timely access to the inpatient care which may result from such outpatient consultations. This is also a mixed state/federal responsibility. Public hospitals have inadequate funds. Governments do claim record funding but that is almost inevitable for most government programs as the population grows. With this population growth, the aging of the population, and increased capacity to treat illnesses better, there is an inevitably increase in demand. What is needed is funding to meet that demand, not record funding. No innovation is required. Instead, a simple commitment the states to adequately fund increased demand would lead to an increase in federal funding to fit with its National Health Reform Agreement commitment to 42.5% of total funding of public hospitals by 2030 under the National Health Reform Agreement. The federal government has, however, maintained a cap on the increase per year it will fund. If states exceed that cap of 8%, it will not be matched by the federal government, even if it is to address increased demand.
However, there is an extra twist. Over 10% of patients in public hospitals are waiting either for aged care placements or what used to be called aged care packages to enable them to stay at home. These are completely the responsibility of the federal government. Once again, it will claim record funding, but it will not be able to claim funding that is adequate for demand.
Increased forced distribution of non-GP specialists
Lastly the Australian Health Practitioners Agency has been innovative in attempting to get non-GP specialists into regional and remote areas of need and documented non-GP specialist shortages through it’s the Expedited Specialist Pathway. The scheme fast-tracks approval of non-GP specialist qualifications for non-GP specialists in a limited number of areas who have qualifications from the UK, Ireland, Canada, and New Zealand. They need to have a 6-month period of supervision, which is usually in an urban setting, and then must commit to working in areas of documented need for 10 years.
A recent report on the scheme showed that only 11% are practicing in regional and remote areas but 88% are practicing in defined areas of workforce shortage, which does include some metropolitan areas. The low number to date of those in rural areas might reflect that the scheme is only 2 years old and many might still be in the supervisory 6-month phase. Hopefully this is a way of improving regional and remote access to care, but it is currently limited to only a small number of specialties.
Fee transparency
Whilst an online record of fees would help some GPs in their choice of non-GP specialist and may help some patients, the complexity of the multiple item numbers is such that it would really only be useful for relatively simple attendances. Even then, however, it has quite reasonably been suggested that such a site may lead to some specialists realizing that they could be charging a lot more like their colleagues do and actually increasing their fees.
Dr Tim Woodruff
President DRS
9 September 2026
28th May 2020
Senate Select Committee on COVID-19
Senate Select Committee on COVID-19
Prepared by Dr Tim Woodruff, President, Doctors Reform Society
The Doctors Reform Society is an organisation of doctors and medical students which formed in 1973 to support the introduction of a universal health insurance scheme (Medibank). It is an organisation which continues to advocate for a health system and a society which aims to address all causes of poor health outcomes for all people irrespective of income, socioeconomic status, race, culture, and geographical location.
Terms of Reference
On 8 April 2020 the Senate established the Select Committee on COVID-19 and referred the following matters to it for inquiry and report on or before 30 June 2022:
the Australian Government’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic; and any related matters.
Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this crucial and ongoing issue. The following is about the response to date and the response as the pandemic evolves and we adjust to the new normal.
The Economy
The pandemic has brought to the fore a realisation firstly that a healthy community helps the economy and secondly that having many Australians with an inadequate income severely compromises the economy. This inter-relationship between an adequate, secure income, health, and the economy must be remembered as we progress our response to the pandemic.
Health
Those in the health field talk about the two major determinants of a healthy community. Firstly, timely affordable access to quality health and preventive care is required. Secondly, we talk about the social determinants of health (SDOH), the conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work and age. Inadequate income, poor education and resulting lack of understanding about illness prevention, domestic violence, homelessness, and discrimination are just some of these important determinants.
The Australian Governments’ Response
The Australian Government’s response to date has resulted in avoidance of the disastrous explosion of cases, which might have overwhelmed our health system. It is to be commended for putting together a team of medical advisors and listening to their advice. That advice has had a strong scientific evidence base despite it requiring assumptions because of the novelty of the virus.
Benefits and Costs
This response has come at a huge economic cost much of which is unavoidable. What has been apparent however is that the Government clearly recognised that the Newstart Allowance was not sufficient to contribute to preventing an even greater economic challenge than we have. The Newstart Allowance was 40% below the poverty line. In the Australian population, 13% currently live in poverty, 17.4% of kids are being raised in poverty, and 40% of children in lone parent families live in poverty (ACOSS 2016). Now most of those fellow Australians receive the Job Seeker payment. It is now a little above the poverty line. No one is saving money on this allowance. Little is wasted. It is being spent and is helping to maintain the economy. Those who have recently lost their jobs will be spending every cent as they try to manage their pre-existing financial commitments.
Future Income Benefits Cuts
From a health perspective, this massive increase in income for our most disadvantaged is overwhelmingly positive. Poverty in rich countries like Australia is very strongly associated with health and social problems (Wilkinson and Pickett). If Job Seeker is reduced to a Newstart level, there will be a return to poverty for the recipients, which will help no one. Whilst in theory the savings might mean we repay the national debt faster than otherwise, recipients will be less healthy, less able to seek work, will spend less, and will place increased demands on health and social services. There may be a net economic loss. There will certainly be a decline in health outcomes.
Alternatives for a More Secure Future: Income Support
The provision of the Job Seeker payment has not surprisingly, been troubled with long queues at Centrelink, inadequate phone response capacity, and major problems for those who have difficulty managing complicated paperwork for whatever reason. How much easier would it have been if we had had a basic income guarantee (BIG)? This is an idea supported across the political spectrum including the conservative capitalist Nobel Prize winning economist Milton Freidman, the Productivity Commission Page 69), and Brian Howe, retired Hawke Government Deputy Prime Minister. No Centrelink queues (with or without physical distancing). No hours on the phone trying to contact Centrelink. No days or weeks waiting for the phone call from Centrelink. No demeaning experience of trying to interact with an organisation with such a focus on stopping rorting that humanity is lost. Even with BIG, huge changes would still have been required. It would however, have been much simpler, faster and less traumatic for all involved.
Alternatives for a More Secure Future: An Integrated Health System
When the trajectory of the pandemic in Australia was upwards there was a major concern regarding the capacity of our health services to cope, both in the community and in hospitals. Some publicly subsidised private hospitals continued to use vital PPEs for elective surgery whilst others were threatening to close for financial reasons despite the real possibility their beds, staff, and equipment might be needed if infection numbers rocketed. Instead, they won a $1.3 billion pay-check from taxpayers before it was clear they would even be needed.
Imagine if instead of using public taxpayer funds to increase the capacity of private hospitals over the last 20 years, we had instead put that money into public hospitals. Sixty percent of elective surgery in now done privately. If most of that was being done in an enlarged public system, we would have a huge increase in bed and ICU capacity easily accessible without any need to pay more money to the private hospital industry.
Imagine if instead of allowing public mental health funding to remain at staggeringly low levels compared to the documented needs, we had used taxpayer funds to develop an integrated community and hospital system of care. The tsunami of increased mental health issues developing as this crisis evolves would at least have been manageable. Despite the commitment of extra funds now to address this crisis, those funds are being spent in a system, which is not a system but a maze of poorly co-ordinated service providers.
Imagine if instead of allowing residential aged care to be subject to market forces and run by Boards with little understanding of health, there had been a health principled base for aged care underwritten by adequate Aged Care Funding Instrument (or other) payments and adequate health informed governance systems. Staff would no longer be on low wages and casual, with perverse incentives to work when they are sick. Residential aged care would no longer be a potential source of infection (all sorts including COVID). Our community would no longer be exposed to agonising decisions about palliative care for the elderly in underserviced environments or in overstretched hospitals not designed or equipped to deal with dementia and aged care. At the moment, either way our senior citizens are likely to die lonely and uncomfortable deaths.
Now is the time to consider an independent single funder for health care tasked with funding and integrating prevention, emergency services, primary health care including dental care, and hospital services using health professionals working in expanded more relevant practices.
Such an organisation must have a remit to fund services which can be demonstrated are effective and which are integrated with other services. Implementing this reform is a long-term project. It could start with controlling all new funding and gathering the data required to establish services based on need across the country and across the health service spectrum. Health service education would be tailored to support this implementation by coordinating education between professions.
Alternatives for a More Secure Future: Essential Medical Supplies and Data
During this crisis, we have been confronted by major challenges relating to supplies of medicines, vaccines, diagnostic testing reagents along with equipment and personal protective equipment. There may be challenges with respect to the equitable distribution of COVID-19 vaccines as they are developed. These problems largely relate to patent laws, which are structured to favour the owners of patents even at the cost of preventable patient suffering and death. The Australian Government has the power to over-ride patents in the interests of public health. It should! (Gleeson and Legge)
In addition, the European Union has put forward a draft resolution for the World Health Assembly for a global pool for rights on data and knowledge that can be of use for the prevention, detection and treatment of COVID-19. The Australian Government should support this measure.
Alternative for a More Secure Future: Telehealth
The advantages of telehealth in this crisis have been very obvious. No more crowded virus loving doctors’ waiting rooms, no unnecessary exposure of patients, medical staff, and medical office workers to rampaging viruses. Patients have frequently found it so much more convenient to address simple issues. Relatives don’t have to take the day off work to bring elderly patients in for a simple quick visit. We already use the technology to enable specialist services to non metropolitan areas.
There are however a variety of concerns.
Sadly there are doctors who are keen to see patients quickly and are not as thorough as we might hope. In general practice these doctors are sometimes identified by the Professional Services Review Board (PSRB) which is able to see Medicare rebate usage. Unfortunately the PSRB is seldom able to identify specialist over-servicing because specialist practice is so varied and the statistics fail to identify outliers.
- Phone and to a lesser extent video calls miss important visual cues.
- Patients clearly sometimes feel the pressure to finish the consult much more than when in person
- Accidental/ incidental issues are less likely to be uncovered than in a face to face consultation
- Fee for service medicine itself is a barrier to the provision of comprehensive integrated care with multiple providers, dealing with patients with multiple morbidities. Doctors and other providers do this every day in public hospitals. On a salary, the decision to ring patients, videoconference them, or ask them in for a face to face consultation is based almost exclusively on what would be in the patients’ best interests. Getting paid doesn’t matter. Telehealth will further entrench fee for service medicine to the detriment of the health system.
What can be done?
We have many salaried doctors and other health professionals. We need more. Aboriginal Controlled Community Health Centres give us one well established model of how this might be done in general practice. Victorian Community Health Centres treating patients generally in more disadvantaged locations provide another model for general practice. Public hospitals, which have been critical to dealing with this pandemic demonstrate that salaried health care can and do provide high quality care without constantly looking to find ways to increase income.
Whilst some might suggest we might limit telehealth to video consultations rather than allowing telephone consultations as has happened with the crisis, such a decision clearly discriminates against those who cannot manage or access the technology. Such people are already the ones who tend to get the least quality health care.
Listening to the Science: Climate Change
It is reassuring that politicians have sought out and accepted scientific advice on how to address the current health crisis. A key lesson to be taken from this response is the importance of evidence and science and the need for greater acceptance of the science of climate change which has the capacity to wreak even more havoc to both our health and our economy over time than this pandemic.
COVID-19: An Opportunity for a Better Future
Hopefully, we will not be going back to a world where welfare recipients are demonised, job seekers are punished, and vulnerable people with a poor education, a mental illness, a drug addiction, or any number of other life challenging conditions/situations are regarded as lazy useless sub-humans. Experience in other countries has shown that it is just these groups which are least equipped to deal with a pandemic. It is these groups which may harbour a resurgence at any time (e.g. migrant workers in Singapore).
It is time to move to a progressive, kinder, caring society which sees every person as valuable, which maximises everyone’s very variable capacity to contribute to society, and which enables rather than hinders the integration of our most vulnerable brothers and sisters.
Jobs need to be secure, not just any job. Income needs to be adequate, not held low in an unsubstantiated belief that that gets people working again in a productive way. Income and wealth disparities need to be reduced. We need to recognise the stark correlation between health and social problems and income.
As we manage our way through this crisis, it is time to think about an integrated, comprehensive, equitable health system. It would be good for the economy. Further, it is time to look at restructuring our society to recognise and address those factors outside the health system, which affect health and therefore affect our economy and our individual well-being.
23rd Oct 2019
Mental Health Productivity Commission draft report: reply
Thank you for the opportunity to respond to your draft report. It is an impressive document with extensive recommendations covering access to appropriate evidence based integrated patient centred care, improved governance, funding models, improved data collection, and other important determinants of optimal care.
This submission is therefore mainly about the gaps in the report recommendations and/or those recommendations with which we disagree or which are insufficient to address the issue. Read more
20th Oct 2019
Submission to the Newstart Inquiry Senate 2019
Senate Community Affairs References Committee
The level of the Newstart payment is a health issue. It is also a productivity issue. It is time to recognise that a Newstart payment 40% below the poverty line impairs both the health and the productivity of recipients and of the broader community.
See full submission here
Submission to the Climate Health WA Inquiry 2019
The Doctors Reform Society of Western Australia has made a submission to the Climate Health WA Inquiry.
We also endorse the submission from the Climate and Health Alliance, of which the Doctors Reform Society is a member.
Submission to the 2017 Review of Australia’s climate change policies
What about health impacts?
The Doctors Reform Society is a health organisation which aims to improve health for all people in a socially just and equitable way. We believe that human health depends fundamentally on a healthy environment. We accept the scientific consensus that anthropogenic global warming is occurring, that this is a great hazard to health, and that urgent action to combat this is required.(1)
It is from our health perspective that we wish to make a brief submission to the current review of Australia’s climate change policies. This complements and in places overlaps with our recent submission to the National Electricity Market review.(2)
We welcome the discussion paper’s acknowledgement that the climate change is a global issue requiring an international response, in which Australia has an important role to play.(3)
However, we note the near-absence of discussion of health in the discussion paper – indeed, the word “health” appears only once, in reference to motor vehicle emissions rather than climate change impacts. It is vital that the Australian government responds to climate change not just as an environmental issue or an energy issue but also as a serious health issue…
Submission to the Independent Review into the Future Security of the National Electricity Market
The Doctors Reform Society is a health organisation which aims to improve health for all people in a socially just and equitable way. We believe that human health depends fundamentally on a healthy environment. We accept the scientific consensus that anthropogenic global warming is occurring, that this is a great hazard to health, and that urgent action to combat this is required.(1)
It is from our health perspective that we wish to make a brief submission in response to the Preliminary Report of the Independent Review into the Future Security of the National Electricity Market.
We welcome the report’s acknowledgement that the Australian electricity sector is a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, its recognition that the transition to a low emissions economy is imminent, and its awareness of the importance of integrating emissions reduction and energy policies.(2)
However, we note the absence of discussion of health in the Preliminary Report – indeed, the word “health” appears nowhere in its pages…
7th Sep 2016
Budget Savings (Omnibus) Bill 2016 Senate Standing Committees on Economics
The Doctors Reform Society of Australia is concerned about the potential adverse health and societal impacts of two aspects of the Budget Savings (Omnibus) Bill 2016.
1. The bill proposes a $1.3 billion cut to the Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA) over the coming 5 years. Many renewable energy researchers believe this likely to have serious negative impacts on renewable energy science in this country.
As a health organisation, we recognise the serious threat that climate change poses to health, both now and increasingly in the future. International health researchers believe climate change to be the biggest global health threat of our century. We believe that Australia needs to play a vigorous role in mitigating climate change. Clean energy technologies will be a vital part of such mitigation.
Cutting funding to such mitigation efforts would be a serious false economy.
2. The bill proposes to cut $4.40 per week from the energy supplement to Newstart recipients. New Newstart recipients receive a payment significantly below the poverty line, and this new cut would reportedly take these people 32% below the poverty line. International evidence finds that less generous unemployment payments are associated with poorer return-to-work outcomes. Inequality and poverty are important drivers of poor health outcomes.
We ask that the committee strike these budget measures from the bill. Indeed, we believe Australia should go further than this, and increase support for renewable energy and unemployed people.
Yours sincerely
Dr Brett Montgomery
on behalf of the Doctors Reform Society
24th Jul 2016
Submission to productivity commission on privatisation
Submission to the Productivity Commission regarding the public inquiry into the increased application of competition, contestability and informed user choice to human services
Thank you for the opportunity to provide a submission.
The Doctors Reform Society is an organisation of doctors and medical students whose aim is to have a health system and a society which optimises the health of Australians. Affordable timely access to high quality culturally appropriate health care is one key to that.
